Rated 3 out of 5 by JudyNY from Love the product, not the applicator Love the product. Stays through tears and rain. Not sure why others say it's so hard to remove. I simply use liquid soap and water, comes off easily at the end of the day. Same with regular store brand make up remover. Yes, it can look like vinyl if applied too thick. I also agree that it's a pain if it gets on your eye lashes. The applicator is horrible, but I LOVE the applicator on the other eye liners that are not water proof - which sucks having to purchase two items to mix and match. Trying to call customer service to ask if I can purchase these applicators separately yields no results.

Date published: 2019-12-01

Rated 5 out of 5 by kristinanns from Well I hate the applicator. It’s like poking your eye out. So I swap applicators with the [product:wet-n-wild-megaliner-liquid-eyeliner] because they are interchangeable packaging that one fits on this & it’s a softer foam tip. I save the applicator for when the foam tip gets all messed up & blunted & put it back on so I can use up all the product inside. This hack is simple I don’t like Mega liner because it’s not waterproof or I’d just use that. This eyeliner is quite waterproof the best cheap waterproof liquid liner you can get. Having the other eye liner’s cap helps some so I don’t poke out an eye ball. I have to buy 2 eyeliners at $3 each to make 1 good eyeliner.

Date published: 2018-08-30

Rated 3 out of 5 by JudyNY from Love the product, not the applicator Love the product. Stays through tears and rain. Not sure why others say it's so hard to remove. I simply use liquid soap and water, comes off easily at the end of the day. Same with regular store brand make up remover. Yes, it can look like vinyl if applied too thick. I also agree that it's a pain if it gets on your eye lashes. The applicator is horrible, but I LOVE the applicator on the other eye liners that are not water proof - which sucks having to purchase two items to mix and match. Trying to call customer service to ask if I can purchase these applicators separately yields no results.

Date published: 2019-12-01

Rated 2 out of 5 by simplyselenaaa from The reason why I give it a 2 is because I tried a swatch on my hand and the liner is really pigment and didn't some off when I put water on it. But when I put it on my eye lid I thought it was really nice because the applicator and very pigmented and dried down to a gorgeous matte finish but sad thing is it was hot the day I tried it out and I don't know why but it smeared on my eyelid I have small eyelids. It was a disappointment. I thought it was going to last me all day, I had just eyeshadow on no water on my eyes maybe because my face and my eyelid tends to get oily which is weird or I was sweating a little and that happened.

Date published: 2018-07-03

Rated 4 out of 5 by stephhsik from This eyeliner is very black and water proof! It definitely holds up and lasts a very long time! I got used to the applicator after a while, so I dont have a problem with it. However, for those that are beginners to eyeliner it might get messed up if youre not steady enough. Also, if youre someone not used to the shape of this kind of applicator at first it might take a few tries for you to get used to it and precise. Sometimes when applying it, it might get on your lashes a little, which could contribute to the lashes being a little clumpy when you go to apply mascara. For the price point, it is amazing and the formula itself can compare to high end eyeliners.

Date published: 2020-07-11

Rated 2 out of 5 by Mary01 from Not for me.. I bought this product a month ago. So far it hasn't been that great. The eyeliner is very hard to remove, I use an oil based makeup remover and it still doesn't remove all the liner. It smears all over my eyelids+under eye area and stains. However it does last long, but I find it's not really worth it if I have to rub my eyes with a cotton pad until my eyelids are hurting. Would not recommend!

Date published: 2019-11-23

Rated 1 out of 5 by Morgann from Not a good eyeliner I got this hoping that it would withstand my oily skin, but instead the lines blur out and the eye liner gets from the bottom part of my lid to the top within the first hour of wear.

Date published: 2018-09-26

Rated 5 out of 5 by kimmy98 from Suprised i love that it doesnt smudge even in pouring rain. ive been using this liquid eyeliner throughout my highschool days but then stopped seeing stock ups at my nearest pharmacy which was sad to me...and made me switch liners. But 5 years later i decided to come back to shop here and im surprised by the reviews it has :( !!!! IF you want a jet black sharp WATERPROOF winged eyeliner and most importantly AFFORDABLE? then i 100/100 RECOMMEND this eyeliner. its called waterproof for a reason ladies :). if youre having trouble removing it, then i suggest NEUTROGENA WATERPROOF MAKE UP WIPES. it works to take off. plus makeup does not come off at one wipe, just keep that in mind.

Date published: 2020-04-20

Rated 5 out of 5 by mariaa104 from I know what some of you might be thinking looking at this but I think I'll leave you one while I step their game up. First I like that there vegan and cruelty-free that is actually important to me. I try to pick natural products I haven't found a liquid liner that I like or an eyeliner that is a natural product. This stuff is great it will not run it will not smudge it will not move. The only thing that I noticed that will take it off is some coconut oil before you wash your face. Microcellular water well not to the trick on this stuff. The only thing that ever made this run is swimming in the pool. Did not irritate my eyes. Does not have a weird smell. Color does not fade.

Date published: 2019-07-29

Rated 1 out of 5 by Mikaela143 from Stains and Hard to remove I bought this eyeliner with hopes that it would be good because Jeffree Star raved about this brand but this eyeliner wasn’t the best. First of all the applicator doesn’t make really thin lines because when the product touches your skin it almost looks like it spreads out. Second it is very hard to remove. I used the micellar water but that didn’t really work, so I used lotion but that also didn’t work. If you want to try this product go ahead but try using an oil based make up remover because the other two I listed didn’t work very well. And last of all, if and when you manage to take it off, it leaves your skin stained. When I was able to take it off, it left the part under my eyes black and makes me look like I haven’t slept in days. I also forgot to mention but I used face wash to try to remove the liner and even that didn’t work so use this liner with caution. I also do have monolids so it does transfer to the top of my lid. I use the roller liner from Revlon and dunk it into this liner to get a thin line.

Date published: 2019-11-05

H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner

Does this go also in the waterline?

#STAYWILD

ACCOUNT

About

Promotions